Explain Shepherding To Submitters

Kent composed this seven paragraph document to explain shepherding to submitters.

  • ascii text [1]

As a shepherd I forwarded it to each of the authors I reviewed. In outline form it says...

  • reviewing
    • we're different
    • you've been assigned a shepherd
    • he has responsibilities
      • judge your submission
      • help you improve
    • expect to correspond
      • several rounds with your shepherd
      • possibly with other shepherds
  • publication
    • takes place after the conference
    • conference committee selects papers
    • you will need to
      • edit guided by conference experience
      • convert to Microsoft Word format
  • criteria
    • we're here to master the form together
    • traditional committees are just gatekeepers
    • we are less interested in content
      • originality
      • correctness
      • grandeur
    • prefer explanations of the ordinary in need of improvement

 

Last edited October 30, 1995
Return to WelcomeVisitors